Pope or Church? / Dom Paul Nau & Canon Rene Berthod

$12.10

Qty Available: 2

Product may vary slightly from image representation.


These two essays address the degree of infallibility enjoyed by acts of the ordinary magisterium. At the time of Pius XII, when the first essay was written, the authority of the ordinary magisterium was downplayed, especially by the "new theologians"; after Vatican II, it is so exaggerated that some now claim the Pope can contradict and reverse the teaching of his predecessors.

The first essay, written by Dom Paul Nau, OSB (Solesmes) in 1956 lays down the groundwork for a theological understanding of the Church's Ordinary and Universal Magisterium, based especially upon the teaching of the First Vatican Council.

The second essay, written in 1980 by Canon Rene Berthod, clearly outlines the universality required for the infallibility of the Ordinary Magisterium and applies it to the present crisis in the Church, and in particular to the teachings of Vatican II, answering the question, to what extent and in what way they can be considered infallible ... or not.

If you are tempted to think that this is a bit too theological and/or technical for you or that it has no practical application to your life, consider this observation of Archbishop Lefebvre who said that the master-stroke of Satan was to foment Revolution in the Church imposed by obedience. Consequently, to avoid this snare of the devil and it's accompanying errors (obedience to modernist directives and, the other extreme, sedevacantism), it is essential to thoroughly understand the Ordinary and Universal Magisterium and the role it plays in the Church, the Mystical Body of Our Lord Jesus Christ.

77pp, softcove

34 item(s), $1,403.35
1 x At Work with John's Gospel (PB) / John Bottomley
At Work with John's Gospel (PB) / John Bottomley
1 x 2023 Catholic Mothers Planner Ring Bound
2023 Catholic Mothers Planner Ring Bound
1 x Priestly Formation in the Human Virtues: Volume 3 -The Priest as a Man of Fortitude (HB) / Fr Angel Pérez-López
Priestly Formation in the Human Virtues: Volume 3 -The Priest as a Man of Fortitude (HB) / Fr Angel Pérez-López
1 x Cornerstone: Encountering the Spirit of Christ in the Catholic School (PB) / William Sultmann
Cornerstone: Encountering the Spirit of Christ in the Catholic School (PB) / William Sultmann
1 x The Women Doctors of the Church / Colleen Pressprich, Illustrated by Adalee Hude
The Women Doctors of the Church / Colleen Pressprich, Illustrated by Adalee Hude
1 x YOUCAT Catechism AU/NZ 2nd Ed
YOUCAT Catechism AU/NZ 2nd Ed
1 x The Sexual Revolution: History, Ideology, Power (PB) / Bishop Peter J Elliott (Author)
The Sexual Revolution: History, Ideology, Power (PB) / Bishop Peter J Elliott (Author)
1 x Commentary on St. Paul's Epistles to the Galatians and Corinthians (HB) / Cornelius ALapidé S.J.
Commentary on St. Paul's Epistles to the Galatians and Corinthians (HB) / Cornelius ALapidé S.J.
1 x A Primer on Fundamental Moral Theology (PB) / Fr. Brian Thomas Becket Mullady O.P.
A Primer on Fundamental Moral Theology (PB) / Fr. Brian Thomas Becket Mullady O.P.
1 x Obedience Paradox / Mary Stanford
Obedience Paradox / Mary Stanford
1 x Andries (PB) / Hilda Van Stockum
Andries (PB) / Hilda Van Stockum
1 x Spiritual Lightning: Answering Your Call from Jesus to Master His Values (PB) / Richard Eason
Spiritual Lightning: Answering Your Call from Jesus to Master His Values (PB) / Richard Eason
1 x On Conscience: Two Essays (HB) / Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger
On Conscience: Two Essays (HB) / Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger
1 x Saint Irenaeus Fathers of the Faith / Mike Aquilina
Saint Irenaeus Fathers of the Faith / Mike Aquilina
1 x Angelo Maria Rinolfi The Preacher / John Michael Hill
Angelo Maria Rinolfi  The Preacher / John Michael Hill
1 x Speaking the Christian God: The Holy Trinity and the Challenge of Feminism (PB) / Alvin F Kimel
Speaking the Christian God: The Holy Trinity and the Challenge of Feminism (PB) / Alvin F Kimel
1 x Sunday Morning Chaos / Kristen Schroder
Sunday Morning Chaos / Kristen Schroder
1 x DVD - POPE BENEDICT XVI
DVD - POPE BENEDICT XVI
1 x The Hell There Is: An Exploration of an Often-Rejected Doctrine of the Church (HB) / Monsignor Charles Pope
The Hell There Is: An Exploration of an Often-Rejected Doctrine of the Church (HB) / Monsignor Charles Pope
1 x Benedictus: Day by Day with Pope Benedict XVI (PB) / Edited by Rev Peter John Cameron OP
Benedictus: Day by Day with Pope Benedict XVI (PB) / Edited by Rev Peter John Cameron OP
1 x Lives of the Saints Volume 7 December and Appendices / Rev Alban Butler
Lives of the Saints Volume 7 December and Appendices / Rev Alban Butler
1 x Betsy's up-and-Down Year (Volume 5) (Latsch Valley Farm Series) (PB) / Anne Pellowski (Author)
Betsy's up-and-Down Year (Volume 5) (Latsch Valley Farm Series) (PB) / Anne Pellowski (Author)
1 x Carlo Acutis Holiness for the
Carlo Acutis Holiness for the
1 x The Angels and Their Mission / Jean Danielou
The Angels and Their Mission / Jean Danielou
1 x Psychology and the Cross / Fr G Emmett Carter
Psychology and the Cross / Fr G Emmett Carter
1 x Elizabeth of the Trinity (PB) / Julie Enzler
Elizabeth of the Trinity (PB) / Julie Enzler
1 x Simply Faithful My Catholic Prayer Journal The Sacred Heart / Barb Szyszkiewicz
Simply Faithful My Catholic Prayer Journal  The Sacred Heart / Barb Szyszkiewicz
1 x A Populism of the Spirit - Further Essays in Politics and Universal Ethics (PB) / Shimon Cowen
A Populism of the Spirit - Further Essays in Politics and Universal Ethics (PB) / Shimon Cowen
1 x Sound of Silence
Sound of Silence
1 x I Can Pray Anywhere (HB) / Donna-Marie Cooper O'Boyle
I Can Pray Anywhere (HB) / Donna-Marie Cooper O'Boyle
1 x Peace in Pregnancy / Kathryn Anne Casey
Peace in Pregnancy / Kathryn Anne Casey
1 x Ego Eimi It Is I / Fr Armand de Malleray FSSP
Ego Eimi It Is I / Fr Armand de Malleray FSSP
1 x Edward King Teacher Pastor Bishop Saint / Bishop Michael Marshall
Edward King Teacher Pastor Bishop Saint / Bishop Michael Marshall
1 x Everything Under the Heavens: How the Past Helps Shape China's Push for Global Power (PB) / Howard W. French
Everything Under the Heavens: How the Past Helps Shape China's Push for Global Power (PB) / Howard W. French